lunedì 12 novembre 2012


What are the arguments of civil society against ACTA?
-ACTA has the potential to severely limit the free flow of information on the web and the free exchange of ideas between people around the world.
-ACTA is useless against counterfeiting. In fact, China, Russia, India and Brazil, the largest producers of counterfeit goods in the world, did not adhere to it and have publicly stated that they never will do it.
-According to the proponents of the agreement, ACTA should protect public health by preventing the spread of fake and dangerous drugs. But these are not crimes and violations of individual property like ACTA claims. According to various organizations, ACTA will therefore have negative effects on access to medicines, especially in the south states.

The protests were numerous throughout the world. Among most important in Europe should enumerate those that occurred in Poland: more than a thousand people protested outside Parliament in Warsaw January 24, 2012; January 25, 15 thousand people protested in Krakow, 5000 in Bratislava. Even in Sweden there has been much disagreement, as well as in Germany.
A real protest was to Kader Arif, the European Parliament ACTA supervisor who resigned from his post denouncing the lack of transparency in the negotiations.
 by Micaela Cancian

1 commento:

  1. Why ACTA? Being on the European Union side.
    This treaty has come in for a great deal of criticism, but I would like also to emphasize other aspects on regarding need of protection measures on intellectual property (IP).
    An OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development) study of 2009 on the global nature of counterfeiting and piracy estimated that international trade in counterfeit goods increased from 100 billion dollars in 2000 to 250 billion dollars in 2007.
    The EU and national customs authorities reported that counterfeit products coming into the EU tripled between 2005 and 2010. These violations threaten the legitimate trade and competitiveness of the UE, with negative consequences for the economic growth and employment.
    The EU and many other countries, which are concerned about their economies due to counterfeiting activities and piracy, they recognize that international cooperation is essential in order to achieve effective protection of intellectual property rights.
    Due to counterfeit goods getting into the European market, Europe each year loses many billions of euros either in revenue and customs duties.
    According to the European Commission, in favour of ACTA, the European economy can stay competitive if it can rely on innovation, creativity, quality and exclusivity of the brand, which are the main comparative advantages in the market world, and they are all protected by intellectual property rights and this also means to have safe products.
    In relation to the application of intellectual property rights (IPR), the EC has conducted a survey in 2008 on the situation of application of IPR outside the European Union, the result of which is a document SEC (2009) 1360 “IPR - Enforcement Report 2009” (http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2009/october/tradoc_145204.pdf) as a tool for companies to make them aware of the risks they incur when they have to deal with certain third countries.
    This assessment is also a tool for the Commission to determine the countries /regions on which to focus its activities and resources, in particular through the establishment of a list of “priority countries” where strengthen the cooperation in IPR.
    In order to gather feedback from European companies and update the list of “priority countries”, in 2010 the EC launched a survey (http://trade.ec.europa.eu/consultations/?consul_id=147) on the protection and enforcement of IPR in third countries.
    These investigations are related to the strategy of the IPR implementation in third countries, adopted in 2004 by the Commission, in order to reduce the level of IPR violations beyond EU’s borders, particularly in countries which has reached alarming proportions, damaging the rights holders of the EU.
    For the Commission, ACTA was (as the EP rejected) an international trade agreement that could have helped countries to cooperate more effectively in dealing with large-scale IPR violations.
    The benefits for the citizens coming from this Agreement would have helped to protect innovations and ideas, because the level of intellectual property protection would have become global, thus protecting jobs.
    This doesn’t mean that I agree with ACTA, on the contrary I remain sceptical. For example with regard to the penalties provided by the Treaty. In fact, every country would have had to regulate in detail the sanctions aspects, with probably different consequences among countries such as more or less heavy penalties.

    Patron Cristina

    RispondiElimina